Lots of media coverage yesterday for various data about the state of the Scottish high street and Scottish consumers. The headline seems to be that 1 in 9 of all Scottish shops are now vacant, though backed up with other recent figures about the lack of footfall in towns, the least disposable income for many years, slow consumer spending and a whole host of doom and gloom.
Buried in one report was a statement that the recession ended last January – but I somehow think that probably did not apply to Scotland, where many of the hard decisions about public sector workers, pay and service reductions have yet to come through the system.
Part of the coverage was about some of the novel ways in which high streets and local authorities could try to do something about their own situations. There have been some minor “cosmetic” works which have made places look better and maybe made possible businesses think about what could be an opportunity – opening up vacant stores for local schools or colleges, mocking up shop fronts to make it look like a store was there, and so on.
There are then the more substantive elements, in many cases funded by the Town Centre Regeneration Fund, such as the innovative Retail Rocks scheme in Torry, Aberdeen (and in which I declare the IRS at Stirling had some hand at the outset).
But on the flip side, there are then the negative things that are happening to our high streets and town centres. One of the most common of these seems to be the raising or the introduction of car parking charges for high streets and town centres. I am regularly sent cuttings about plans to increase the “take” from car parking, from centres across Scotland. The latest has been a steady stream of emails about Alloa, where there is a worry that the local authority wants to end the free local car parks and the local BID is fighting the proposals.
Whilst there are lots of things to debate about car use and costs generally, and I understand the problems cash-strapped local authorities are facing, it does seem a difficult time to be adding to the dis-incentives for people to visit local high streets and towns. Anything that makes it harder or actually/perceived to be more expensive will act as a barrier and have the effect of reducing the attractiveness of a place. Footfall and spending are in tough enough places already. Whilst car parking costs are not on the scale of petrol costs, they are seen differently, and centres that impose or obviously raise them at this time, may be a trigger to re-evaluate behaviours, and not in a positive sense for that town or high street.
It is a recurrent theme, but high streets depend on people visiting them and they make their decisions on the ways in which high streets and their competition satisfy or not their requirements. What makes this high street the place to go, and how can we improve the experience, whether in the short term or the medium term, should be questions at the forefront of everyone’s minds.
The retailers need to give parking incentive to the customers and although small but can be a reason to keep up the footfall in the stores.Everyone wins!
Kassel in Germany converted a number of lightly used rural train lines to TramTrain which connected to the town tram system and the Chamber of Commerce have reported an increase of 32% footfall in the town centre.
There are no trams in Scotland you may say, but there are a goodly number of underused heavy rail lines and the McNullty Report recommend these to be converted to TrainTram. Later this month, Norman Baker MP, Minister for Transport will unveil his “Light Rail review” which as a contributor will show how low cost tramways (NOT the EDINBURGH Model) can be built for smaller cities and towns and connecting to the heavy rail lines can make the Kassel phenomena happen in Scotland
Thanks for the comment. Don’t know enough about the rail lines that could be used, so look forward to learning more. I do know that the case for the re-opening of the Alloa line (and the post was partly about Alloa) woefully underestimated the actual demand that materialised. I wonder how many other cases for investment are like wise missed. I dare not comment on Edinburgh trams – how can it get to that?